Detecting Check Fraud: Key Indicators and Prevention Strategies

In the ever-evolving landscape of banking, the threat of check fraud looms large, presenting a significant risk to the integrity of financial transactions. As leaders in the field, we understand that effective fraud risk assessment and check fraud detection are crucial for protecting both our institutions and our customers. Checks remain a common payment instrument and, consequently, a target for fraudsters. The sophistication of fraudulent techniques, from creating entirely fabricated checks to altering legitimate ones, requires us to continuously adapt and enhance our defensive strategies.

At the core of our commitment to combating financial crime is a robust, technology-driven approach. We prioritize the deployment of image forensic AI to identify red flags indicative of check fraud, staying ahead of malfeasance in its various forms. By scrutinizing checks for inconsistencies in handwriting, variations in formatting and check stock, and alterations to a field on the check, we refine our fraud detection process ensuring a high level of accuracy and a minimal impact on transaction fluidity.

Understanding Check Fraud

Check fraud is a critical issue that requires vigilant detection and evolving prevention efforts. It’s vital to stay informed about the different types of check fraud and the latest trends, especially given the increased opportunities for fraudsters during the recent global health crisis.

Types of Check Fraud

Check fraud can occur in various forms, including:

Counterfeit checks, created to look genuine and often printed with stolen account information. 

Forged checks, where the fraudster illegally endorses a check not addressed to them.

Altered checks involve changing the payee’s name or the amount on a legitimate check. 

Our systems must recognize these fraudulent activities to protect our stakeholders.

Recent Trends Impacting Fraud

The recent global health crisis has impacted fraud trends significantly. The industry has observed an increase in stolen checks, with criminals targeting mailboxes and mail carriers. These checks are being sold on the dark web, where they end up either altered or washed, or the information is used to create counterfeits. Remote banking, which has become more popular, can be more susceptible to these bogus checks as check images need only be converted to bi-tonal images, hiding any physical damage or changes to the check. 

Red Flags and Warning Signs

In our efforts to safeguard banking institutions, we focus on the hallmarks of potential check fraud. These hallmarks allow us to deploy effective countermeasures and advance our fraud prevention strategies.

Behavioral Indicators

Unusual Rush: A common red flag in check fraud is when clients urge bank staff to rush transactions, bypassing normal processing times. This can indicate an attempt to cash a fraudulent check before it is identified.

Vague Details: Clients who are vague about the origins of a check or unwilling to provide comprehensive background information may raise suspicions. Our vigilance in these scenarios is crucial.

Geographical cues: Oftentimes, stolen checks are deposited at bank branches located several states away. Monitoring where checks are being deposited can offer a key indicator of fraudulent checks.

Documentary Clues

Altered Checks: Discrepancies such as irregularities in the handwriting, font types, or ink used, may indicate an altered check. Checks whose amount, payee name, or other details appear to have been tampered with necessitate further scrutiny.

Variance in check stock: While fraudsters have adopted technologies such as Adobe Photoshop or simply download check templates, these digitally created checks will inevitably have variances in the check stock such as field location. 

Inconsistent signature: Handwritten signatures have certain identifiable features such as how loops of letters are written to how letters are connected. Fraudsters will attempt to replicate these signatures, but there are signs from heavier strokes to “bleed points” where the fraudster holds the pen against the check paper too long. 

The challenges we face in detecting fraudulent checks require a comprehensive approach that includes awareness of behavioral and documentary red flags. By understanding and identifying these signs, we reinforce our commitment to maintaining the integrity of every transaction within our banking operations. Robust fraud solutions allow us to continually adapt to sophisticated tactics deployed by fraudsters, ensuring the utmost protection for our clients and our institution.

Legal Framework and Reporting

Within the banking industry, compliance with legal frameworks and conducting mandatory reporting forms the cornerstone of a robust check fraud detection and prevention strategy. As leaders in this domain, we understand the intricacies of such requirements and the importance of adhering to them.

Regulatory Requirements

Regulatory bodies such as the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) obligate financial institutions to deploy sophisticated measures for the detection and prevention of check fraud. Specific regulations mandate the examination of checks for uncharacteristic transactions, which can indicate fraudulent activity. Through the use of advanced check compliance software, such as ours, banks can extract and analyze critical check information efficiently.

Regulations also encompass safeguarding transactions involving the U.S. mail, as mail fraud schemes often intertwine with check fraud. We must maintain rigorous procedures that can ascertain the legitimacy of every transaction passing through the U.S. Postal Service.

Mandatory Reporting

When suspected fraud is detected, banking institutions must file Suspicious Activity Reports (SARs) with FinCEN. This documentation is vital in communicating potential fraud to law enforcement agencies, including the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), facilitating their investigation and response to fraudulent activities. Our role is pivotal in ensuring that SARs are filed accurately and promptly, reflecting any suspicious transactions that may involve tampering with checks or exploiting the mail system.

Staying ahead of regulatory requirements and maintaining strict adherence to reporting protocols safeguards not only the reputation of banks but also their customers’ assets. It’s our ongoing commitment to deploy state-of-the-art technologies and refined processes, ensuring every transaction stands up to regulatory scrutiny and our high standards of fraud prevention.

Preventive Measures and Best Practices

In combating check fraud, banks must deploy a combination of strict policies and comprehensive training programs. These measures are critical in deterring and detecting potential fraud.

Developing Robust Policies

Proactive fraud mitigation begins with establishing strong policies and procedures. We must regularly update our banking institution’s policies to reflect the latest fraud trends. This includes defining clear lines of accountability and ensuring that AML (Anti-Money Laundering) standards are integrated into the fabric of our operations. The use of image forensic AI technology enhances efforts by identifying counterfeited, altered, or forged check image files, contributing to a robust defense against fraudulent activities.

Employee Education and Training

A well-informed staff is crucial to the fight against check fraud. Regular, targeted training equips employees with the knowledge to spot red flags. Training programs must include simulations of realistic fraud scenarios, so team members can practice identifying and responding to signs of fraud efficiently. Ensuring that all employees understand the importance of compliance and are familiar with the bank’s protocols will create a stronger, more vigilant workforce.

Dealing with Check Fraud Incidents

When faced with check fraud incidents, it’s imperative to act swiftly to mitigate losses and develop longer-term strategies to prevent recurrence. Below are the measures we can take to address and combat these fraudulent activities effectively.

Immediate Actions

Immediate actions are crucial when a check fraud incident is detected to minimize financial losses and gather evidence. Upon discovery:

1. Contact Authorities: Notify the U.S. Postal Inspection Service if the fraud involves mail or schemes like foreign lotteries or mystery shopper scams.
2. Alert the Better Business Bureau: Report the incident to the Better Business Bureau, which can issue alerts and inform others in the industry.
3. Stop Payment: If possible, issue a stop payment order on any fraudulent checks.
4. Verify Payee Information: Utilize payee verification technology to confirm the legitimacy of the payee on any checks in question.

Long-Term Solutions

Implementing long-term solutions helps prevent check fraud from becoming a recurring challenge for our banking institution.

• Strengthen Internal Controls: Periodically evaluate and enhance internal controls to detect fraudulent activity early.
• Deploy Advanced Analytics: Use analytics to recognize patterns indicative of cons like the overpayment scam.
• Educate Staff and Clients: Regularly update staff and customers on common fraud indicators and reporting processes.
• Leverage Technology: Invest in technology that validates checks at the time of presentation to prevent alteration and counterfeit scams.

Through these immediate and long-term strategies, you can continue to protect your assets and customers from the substantial impact of check fraud.

Resources and Support

In our ongoing efforts to combat check fraud, understanding the resources and support available is fundamental. These entities offer valuable insights and assistance to bolster our strategies for check fraud detection.

Public Agencies

• Federal Trade Commission (FTC): The FTC provides extensive information on avoiding and reporting fake check scams. They have materials that can enhance our educational programs for employees and customers.
• U.S. Postal Inspection Service: This federal law enforcement agency focuses on protecting the mail system and offers resources on mail theft and check fraud. Their assistance is vital in investigating and addressing fraud involving the U.S. mail.

Private Organizations

Better Business Bureau (BBB): Renowned for consumer protection and industry self-regulation, the BBB supplies data and reviews on businesses, which can be instrumental in our analysis of check fraud trends and incidents.

We at OrboGraph prioritize keeping abreast with the latest in check fraud detection. By actively engaging with these public agencies and private organizations, we continue to refine our approaches and deploy cutting-edge technology, ensuring that banking processes remain secured against the threat of fraudulent checks being altered and passed into the banking system.

Solution to the Check Fraud Pandemic

OrboGraph has been delivering proven results to combat check fraud for over 15 years. The solution to identifying the unique characteristics of today’s check fraud is based on a blend of AI-based technologies, which we refer to as image forensics.

There are several modules available from OrboGraph that can help:

• Anywhere Fraud is a specialized module within OrboAnywhere designed to detect check fraud by interrogating the attributes of check images to create a risk score based on the probability of the item being a counterfeit check, forged signature, or altered check. Building upon these scores, the system uses self-learning account profiles to create a statistical representation of the account’s check writing habits and styles. Anywhere Fraud also includes targeted transaction analysis.

• Anywhere Positive Pay uses targeted OCR on images of pre-printed business checks and compares the recognized payee names to the payee field of the issue file to proactively identify payee alterations.
• Anywhere Validate automatically validates the negotiability of paper-originated items for any self-service, centralized or distributed capture channel or image exchange trading partner within the omnichannel of a financial institution. Designed to minimize the risk of checks and cash equivalent images from being non-negotiable, the system is a more comprehensive approach compared to traditional image quality, image usability, and/or manual review processes.
• Anywhere Compliance uses advanced check recognition technologies to extract a range of field data from checks and other paper-originated negotiable payments.  Fields include the payor, payee, bank and amount data. This information is then used to mitigate compliance risk in the areas of OFAC, BSA/AML, Reg CC, UCC and KYC.
• Anywhere Payee utilizes enriched recognition technologies applied to the payee field on personal and business checks as a method to validate the correct “pay to the order of” name on a check to detect and reduce deposit fraud. Certain workflows are more sensitive to having the correct payee on a checks where posting errors, illegal payees or fraudulent payees are prevalent. 

Schedule a Demonstration

Leveraging OrbNet AI and OrbNet Forensic AI technology for check processing and check

fraud detection. Schedule a demonstration.